Blog
SEO, UX or a redesign: what does your website actually need?
If your website is not bringing the right enquiries, it is tempting to start with a solution: improve the SEO, make it easier to use, or replace the whole site.
The useful first question is where people are getting stuck. Can potential customers find you? Can they understand your offer and take the next step? Can your current website support what the business needs?
Each answer points to different work. This guide will help you decide what to investigate before committing to a project.
Start with the job your website needs to do
Choose one specific outcome, such as enquiries for a particular service, completed bookings, or purchases of a product range. “More traffic” alone does not tell you whether the website is helping the business.
Then check the basics. Does the contact form reach your inbox? Does the booking link work on a phone? Are recorded enquiries consistent with what actually arrives? A broken form or missing tracking can make a website appear to have a wider problem than it does.
With that foundation checked, look at three possible priorities.
Prioritise SEO when relevant customers struggle to find you
Search engine optimisation helps search engines discover and understand your pages, while making the content useful for people searching for what you offer. The aim is visibility for relevant searches.
An SEO review makes sense when important services are hard to find in search, the site attracts people looking for something else, or useful pages are missing from Google’s index.
Look at the queries and pages in Google Search Console. Separate searches for your business name from searches for your services, and check whether the countries and devices match your audience. A lack of impressions is a reason to investigate demand, content and technical access; it does not identify the cause by itself.
For example, imagine a decorating business whose website puts every service on one vague page. Research might support a clearer page for exterior painting, with useful service details and links from relevant pages. That could be a focused content and SEO project without a full rebuild.
Glara’s SEO services connect these findings to practical changes and measurement.
Prioritise UX when people struggle to understand or act
User experience, or UX, concerns how well the website helps people complete their tasks. That includes finding information, understanding an offer and using an enquiry or booking process.
Useful warning signs include repeated customer questions that the site should answer, confusing navigation, unclear buttons, or people getting stuck in forms. More visits with few enquiries can be a clue, but first check visitor relevance, the offer and whether enquiries are being measured correctly.
Watch a few people who resemble your customers attempt a realistic task, such as finding the right service and requesting a quote. Ask them to explain what they expect as they go. Avoid guiding them past the confusing parts.
Imagine a repair company with relevant visitors but an enquiry form that asks for technical details customers do not know. A clearer explanation, better field labels and fewer required questions may be worth testing before changing the whole site.
Include accessibility in the review. Check keyboard use, readable text and understandable form instructions, and involve people with disabilities where possible. A quick usability check is only a starting point for a fuller accessibility evaluation.
Our UX/UI design services focus on these journeys, structures and interactions.
Consider a redesign when the existing site limits necessary changes
A redesign becomes more useful when problems affect much of the website or its underlying setup. Perhaps your services have changed, the page structure no longer fits, mobile layouts fail across key pages, or the platform makes essential updates difficult to maintain.
Visual design can matter too. Outdated information, inconsistent presentation and unreadable layouts can make it harder for visitors to assess the business. Be specific about what needs to improve: age or personal taste alone is a weak project brief.
Ask whether the problem needs a content edit, a template change, a targeted repair or a wider rebuild. For example, a restaurant expanding into catering may need a new service page and enquiry route. A full redesign makes more sense if the current system cannot support those changes reliably.
Before changing existing URLs, plan where each old page will lead and which redirects are needed. Preserve useful content and check important journeys after launch. Glara’s web design and development services bring these decisions into the website project.
Expect some overlap
A clear service page can help both search visibility and visitor understanding. Better navigation can make pages easier for people and search engines to discover. A redesign can make these improvements easier to implement, but it can also introduce problems if important content or URLs disappear.
You may need a combination, with a clear order. Fix a broken enquiry route promptly. Resolve a confirmed indexing obstacle before investing heavily in new content. Test an uncertain journey before rebuilding it across the site.
Five checks before you choose a project
- Define a useful result. Name the service, audience and action you want to improve. Include enquiry quality, not just volume.
- Check what the evidence can tell you. Compare search data, website activity and real enquiries. Allow for seasonal demand and small samples. For a new site with little data, start with customer conversations and task testing.
- Follow the whole journey. Review the search result, landing page and next step together. Check a phone as well as a computer, including successful submission and error messages.
- Identify the smallest worthwhile change. Ask what it addresses, why it should help and whether the current site can support it. A focused improvement may be easier to test and maintain.
- Agree how to review progress. Record a baseline, the changes, who will implement them and when to review them. Search changes can take time; avoid judging them after a few days.
Choose the next step from the evidence
If the main obstacle is relevant search visibility, begin with SEO. If suitable visitors struggle with a specific task, investigate UX. If the site’s structure or technology prevents the changes you need, assess a redesign.
When the evidence is mixed, a focused review can help you choose a sensible starting point. You do not need to commit to every discipline at once.
At Glara, we connect websites, SEO and UX around what the business needs to achieve. Tell us what your website needs to do, what is not working today and the constraints you are working with.
Images: AI-generated editorial illustrations.
